Monthly Archives: January 2003

The Good Soldiers by David Finkel

Standard
The Good Soldiers by David Finkel

David Finkel. The Good Soldiers. Sarah Crichton Books, 2009. ISBN 978-0374165734 304 pp. $

*****

The Good Soldiers follows the deployment of 2-16, sent to Baghdad as part of the “last surge” in 2007. As part of the counterinsurgency movement, soldiers prowl the streets at 10 miles an hour, looking for explosive devices and rebels. Colonel Kauz goes on the local radio to try to gain the trust of the Iraqi people. The daughter of a translator gets a piece of glass embedded in her face. Birthdays are celebrated, the president visits the wounded, wives struggle at home as their husbands soldier on.

I devoured The Good Soldiers in three sittings, and found it powerfully moving and well-written. It’s dramatic without being sensationalistic, and author’s opening chapter, filled with foreboding (as the outcome of some of the soldier’s stories are already known as the book opens), leaves the reader filled with dread. It’s an easy read in terms of accessibility, and presents history with judgment reserved in a just the facts, journalistic style; it’s a very hard read because of the subject matter.

With the average age of the majority of the soldiers in 2-16 being 19, this seems like a good choice for teen readers, most especially those who are military minded.

Emily and the Scot by Kathryn Smith

Standard
Emily and the Scot by Kathryn Smith

Smith, Kathryn. Emily and the Scot. Avon, 2003. ISBN 978-0060006198 282 pp. $

****

Highlander Jaime MacLaughlin is a talented leathersmith unafraid of hard work or a little dirt. When he meets his cousin Laird Ewan’s half sister Emily, a fragile-looking society blossom, the two take such an instant dislike to one another it is obvious they must be star-crossed. The English lass tames the savage Scot as he develops dining room manners and learns to waltz, and her pretenses and prejudices are replaced by vigor and health. A disaster in the community makes them pull together, while Ewan’s wife Anna’s gentle meddling gives the lovers a prod in the right direction. The plot suggests that readers may want to go back and read Ewan and Anna’s story, and hints at a romantic adventure between mutual friends as well.

Tame, predictable and safe for middle school readers, these short and uncomplicated romances are like chocolates–some are higher quality than others, occasionally there is a surprise in the middle, and a sweetness lingers when you are finished. A steady diet is not recommended, but once in awhile, it’s ok to splurge on mind candy.